5 Ways Designers Are Making Statement Decor Fit In and Stand Out

The bold seating choice meant her designer, Crystal Sinclair, needed to tweak her game plan. To play up the couch, Ms. Sinclair created a luxe black-and-white color scheme around the sofa and a striped ceiling. Sourcing the perfect shade of pillows and making sure the ceiling’s green-and-white stripes looked straight from below took trial and error. “We had to really work with it,” says the designer from Tuxedo Park, N.Y.

Homeowners—never easy clients—seem to be more insistent than ever on having their favorite bold pieces front and center as they redecorate their homes, thanks, in part, to ever-easier access to ever-increasing choices. That reality has their designers—typically used to having the final say—sharpening one of their least-favorite tools: compromise.

These homeowners are taking a buy-now, think-later approach and leaving it to the experts to work their magic, says Anthony Barzilay Freund, editorial director at 1stdibs, a vintage-furniture and décor site.

Online searches for “statement pieces” increased by 15% since last year, with furniture-style categories such as Japonisme, Rococo, Art Deco and Space Age gaining in popularity, according to 1stdibs data. “People are intrigued by something that has really cool lines or in a color that’s a little bit outrageous,” says Mr. Barzilay Freund. “They want a piece that’s not necessarily pretty or polite, but is sort of a talking point.”

Here is how some designers work to integrate their clients’ must-haves:

Bold Seating

New York interior designer Elena Frampton says she is fielding more requests to add unique and colorful seating, rather than more-common minimal boxy furniture, to main living areas. The larger curved or rounded pieces that now are in demand tend to do better in larger rooms or open-concept living areas alongside a mix of geometric furniture, she says.

For a recent project, figuring out where to put a lavender Cloverleaf sofa by Verner Panton in her client’s Manhattan loft took weeks of virtually experimenting with configurations, says Ms. Frampton. The $17,400 modular couch with three distinct curves and seating on either side was too upright for lounging. “It almost feels like something that would be in a hotel lobby,” says Ms. Frampton.

Ultimately, Ms. Frampton decided to add seating near a floor-to-ceiling window bordering a living-room setup in the space. The sofa allows the owner to use it for entertaining but leaves room for a more practical—and comfortable—seating corner surrounding a coffee table. She added a bold mix of shapes, including a spiked coral sculpture, so the piece wouldn’t stick out in the main living areas. “Even on projects where we have a carte blanche there’s always one wild card,” she says.

Statement Heirlooms

Beloved pieces passed down through generations are a delicate subject because of the added sentimental value and the client’s attachment to a particular item, says designer Keren Richter, of White Arrow in New York. When her client loves the style of the heirloom, she often uses it as a starting point and makes sure to highlight the piece within a room rather than “covering it with pillows.” When planning, she includes photos of the item in client inspiration boards along with any other predetermined home features, including moldings, doorways and floors.

Recently, Ms. Richter created a room that highlights a rare 60-year-old George Nakashima coffee table. The designer combined the midcentury wood-slab, V-shape table with natural fibers and a hanging branch. “There’s a sense of movement and nature in that space, but it’s also clean and modern,” says Ms. Richter.

Table owner Sandra Schpoont says it was important that the eye goes right to the piece that’s standing at the center of the room. She still remembers tagging along with her father to purchase the table in 1962 for $225. Similar ones now sell for more than $30,000.

“I wanted it to stand out,” says the attorney, who worked with Ms. Richter to design her vacation home in Martha’s Vineyard. “It’s the most important piece of furniture I have.”

One-Of-A-Kind Lighting

Integrating a vintage Hollywood spotlight and tripod into her client’s home without feeling overly theatrical took some fiddling, says Los Angeles-based designer Jhoiey Ramirez. The 1930s Mole Richardson Type 210 light, which her client purchased tarnished and broken, took months to restore and cost $5,500. Once it was done, he asked Ms. Ramirez to find a spot that highlights the glamour.

“He ordered it and is like, ‘Make this work,’ ” she says.

Originally, the light was intended for the living area, but the fireplace and other items made it feel cluttered, she says. “It was going to get lost in the living room, there were too many artifacts,” she says, referring to his collection of vintage items.

Instead, the light wows from a corner of the bedroom and stands out among more organic materials, including a wood platform bed and built-in shelving. “When you open the door, you see it right away; there’s nothing distracting your eye,” she says.

Curating Collections

When working on what she calls “a sophisticated hunting lodge” outside of Cotulla, Texas, designer Anne Grandinetti wasn’t prepared for the sheer number of deer-head mounts that showed up on site. In total, Ms. Grandinetti, a designer at Mark Ashby Design in Austin, incorporated more than 30 deer head mounts while leaving wall space for the collection to grow. (The collection cost $30,000, or roughly $1,000 per mount.)

To keep the deer from overwhelming the space, she added the mounts to the wide hallway with a 14-foot ceiling that runs the entirety of the 11,000-square-foot home, while placing a few select pieces in other rooms. She kept the hallway walls and floor area sparse, while adding copper custom lighting made by local artisans.

“We tried to sprinkle them in and spread them out, so it doesn’t feel like a taxidermy showroom,” says Ms. Grandinetti.

Homeowner Rod Meagher, 64, a retired real-estate appraiser, says his goal was to showcase both white-tailed and exotic species of deer without turning to dark traditional ranch décor.

“I wanted it to be clean cut,” says Mr. Meagher of his weekend eight-bedroom, 10-bathroom home that was completed in 2019.

Dramatic Wall Art

After Miami designer Brittany Farinas saw an art piece her client asked her to incorporate into his home, she wasn’t sure where it would fit. The oversize photography still, signed by photographer Terry O’Neill, of actress Raquel Welch posing partially clothed on a cross would be the centerpiece of any room.

“It’s different and very particular,” Ms. Farinas says of the image, which was originally shot as part of a series of publicity photos for the 1966 film “One Million Years B.C.” but wasn’t used.

Ultimately, Ms. Farinas found a spot for the $10,500 photograph on a bedroom wall, adding black accents and dark granite throughout the room. “I wanted to bounce off what that art piece is, which is dark and moody,” she says of the room’s décor. Adding a bold art piece helped visually separate the bed from a seating area and dry bar nook at the far end of the room, she adds.

Not all designers are eager to accommodate requests. Recently, Ms. Sinclair, of Tuxedo Park, N.Y., turned down a client with a statement art piece that didn’t appeal to her. She said she felt it was loud. Instead of taking on the project, she referred the person to a design colleague that would better appreciate the style. “Sometimes it’s telltale of how we’re going to mesh,” she says.

Write to Alina Dizik at alina.dizik@wsj.com